CARC 238 Active

PR-238: Ineligible Coverage Period Reduction

TL;DR

The patient owes the charges for the dates they were not covered. Verify eligibility dates, then bill the patient or appeal with proof of continuous coverage.

Action
Collect from Patient
Who Pays
Patient
Appeal
Yes
Patient Impact
Direct Financial
Disclaimer
This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional billing advice. Always verify information against your payer contracts and current coding guidelines. Consult a certified billing specialist for specific claim issues.

What Does PR-238 Mean?

PR-238 is the only valid group code for this adjustment. The charges for the ineligible coverage period are the patient's direct financial responsibility. The payer has already processed the eligible portion of the claim, and this adjustment represents only the ineligible period reduction.

CARC 238 is a coverage period adjustment. The payer has identified that the claim's dates of service span across both an eligible (covered) period and an ineligible (uncovered) period. Rather than rejecting the entire claim, the payer processes the eligible portion and reduces payment for the dates falling within the ineligible period. The reduction amount is assigned to the patient under Group Code PR.

This typically occurs when a patient's insurance coverage starts or ends mid-treatment, when there is a gap in coverage due to premium non-payment, or when coverage is retroactively terminated to a date that falls within the claim's service period. It is most commonly seen on institutional claims for multi-day stays (inpatient admissions, skilled nursing, long-term care) where the admission spans across a coverage boundary.

CARC 238 is distinct from CARC 239 (which tells you to rebill as separate claims). With 238, the payer has already done the splitting — they paid the eligible portion and reduced for the ineligible portion. The ineligible amount is the patient's responsibility.

Common Causes

Cause Frequency
Claim spans coverage start or end date The claim includes services rendered both before coverage became effective (or after it terminated) and during the active coverage period, requiring the payer to split the charges and assign the ineligible portion to the patient Most Common
Coverage gap during the service period The patient had a lapse in coverage during the dates of service on the claim, such as a period between insurance plans or a premium non-payment suspension, creating an ineligible window within the claim's date range Common
Delayed eligibility updates not reflected in claim The patient's coverage status changed during the service period but the provider's records were not updated in time, resulting in services being billed during a period when the patient was no longer covered Common
Retroactive coverage termination The patient's insurance coverage was retroactively terminated to a date that falls within the claim's service period, making a portion of the charges ineligible after the fact Occasional

How to Resolve

Verify the patient's eligibility dates against the claim, confirm whether the ineligible period reduction is correct, and either bill the patient or appeal with proof of coverage.

  1. Confirm the ineligible period dates Verify with the payer exactly which dates of service fall in the ineligible period and the amount assigned to the patient.
  2. Check for other coverage Determine if the patient had other insurance active during the ineligible period (prior plan, spouse's plan, COBRA, Marketplace). If so, submit the ineligible charges to that payer.
  3. Bill the patient or appeal If no other coverage exists and the dates are correctly identified as ineligible, bill the patient. If coverage was actually active, appeal with enrollment documentation.

Common RARC Pairings

The RARC code tells you exactly what triggered the PR-238:

RARC Description
N130 Remainder of charges are the patient's responsibility.
N657 This adjustment reflects the ineligible coverage period.

How to Prevent PR-238

General Prevention

Related Denial Codes

Sources

  1. https://www.mdclarity.com/denial-code/238
  2. https://x12.org/codes/claim-adjustment-reason-codes
  3. Codes maintained by X12. Visit x12.org for official definitions.